Narragansett, R.I .-- January 9, 2003 -- With fewer than
300 northern right whales remaining, the seriously endangered
species may face yet another obstacle to recovery. The right
whale is regularly exposed to the neurotoxins responsible for
paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP) through feeding on
contaminated zooplankton. These toxins could affect
respiratory capabilities, feeding behavior, and ultimately the
reproduction condition of the whale population.
In the current issue of the journal Harmful Algae, a team
of scientists, led by University of Rhode Island Graduate
School of Oceanography (GSO) biologist Edward Durbin,
describes how north Atlantic right whales, feeding in Grand
Manan Basin in the lower Bay of Fundy in late summer, are
exposed to PSP toxins from feeding directly on the
contaminated copepod Calanus finmarchicus.
Other members of the scientific team include Gregory
Teegarden, St. Joseph’s College, Standish, ME; Robert
Campbell, GSO; Allan Cembella, Institute for Marine
Biosciences, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada; and Mark F.
Baumgartner and Bruce R. Mate, College of Oceanic and
Atmospheric Sciences, Oregon State University.
The scientists estimated that the toxin ingestion rates of
right whales in Grand Manan Basin are substantial and are
similar to the estimated minimum lethal oral dose for humans.
"While there is no direct evidence of PSP toxin-related
deaths of right whales," said Durbin, "we suggest that during
their prolonged summer feeding period in this region, they
would be experiencing chronic exposure to PSP toxins."
The toxins are potent sodium-channel blockers in muscles
and membranes and affect nerve function. Initial symptoms of
PSP toxicity include parethesia and numbness and a weakening
of muscles. In high doses, the PSP toxicity syndrome in
mammals is characterized by respiratory difficulties, which
may cause death in the absence of ventilatory support.
"Although PSP toxins do not tend to accumulate in most
mammalian tissues, chronic effects of repeated PSP toxin
exposure will be seen in measures of diving capabilities,
including dive times, swimming speeds while at depth, and
frequency of dives," added Durbin. "Impaired diving
capabilities in right whales would lead to reduced ingestion
rates and may be a possible explanation for their poorer
condition and reduced calving rates despite the high
concentrations of copepods in Grand Manan Basin."
Other effects of toxin ingestion on "whale fitness" may be
greater susceptibility to disease, reproductive failure,
disruption of migration and mechanical damage, e.g., by
collisions with ships or fouling in nets and other fishing
gear. For example, recovery from dives during periods of PSP
exposure would likely be longer than normal, and increased
time at the surface would increase a whale’s chances of being
hit by a ship.
"The significance of ingested PSP toxins on the survival of
right whales should not be underestimated," said Durbin. "Few
studies have been done on the effects of these toxins on
higher mammals, and none on the effects in whales. Our
findings are the first to suggest that physiological
impairment due to exposure to high dosages of PSP toxins
through the food chain may compromise the health of a
population."
This research project was supported by the National Science
Foundation, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration, the Office of Naval Research, the NASA Space
Grant and Earth System Science Programs, Oregon State Marine
Mammal Endowment, and the National Marine Fisheries
Service.